Bianca Benvenuti is the advocacy manager for Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) in Libya. Here, she talks about the people she met while working in detention centers in the capital city of Tripoli, where thousands of migrants are stranded in appalling conditions.
Libya is not a safe country—we hear that a lot. It has been proven time and time again. Yet I still believe many people do not grasp the true meaning of it.
In December , the MSF medical team received a phone call: There was a woman in the emergency room at Tripoli University Hospital, she’d been there for two days already, had received some basic supportive management and undergone some tests, but the doctors there could not admit her due to lack of documents and no next of kin. They asked MSF to assist. We took her to the referral clinic and transferred her to intensive care almost immediately. But her condition was dire, our doctors saw that not much could be done to save her. After few days, she passed away. We never knew where she was from or who she was. We couldn’t even call her family to tell them she had died and our staff had to assume the responsibility for the release of her body.
After few days, she passed away. We never knew where she was from or who she was. We couldn’t even call her family to tell them she had died.
[Most] refugees and migrants in Libya have no rights. They cannot live a normal life. If criminals target you, you can’t go to the police as they might end up arresting you. If your employer decides not to pay you, there is nothing you can do about it. As you walk back home from work, tired and frustrated, you might be arrested and taken to a detention center.
When I met [17-year-old Hasan] he was staring at his feet. “We eat on the floor,—on the very floor where we sleep, in the same room where we go to the toilet. It is disgusting. What person would force another to live like this?”
[Hasan’s] hands were so dry the skin was falling off. I asked him what happened, and he told me it is from hard manual work. He came to Libya to work, to send money back home to help his family. Unfortunately, too often in the last year he would work and not get paid. He told me he did not feel safe even where he lives. He said he sleeps fully dressed because criminals come to rob them at night. For people like Hasan, Libya is lawless.
I have heard similar stories many times, especially in the neighborhoods of Tripoli where refugees and migrants try to live normal lives. Criminal gangs and militias systematically target these communities. There is not much to steal, but people often tell us you can be killed just for a phone.
Living in fear
Osman is a young boy with a broad smile. He left Somalia because of the war. He was looking for a safer place and he decided to travel to Europe. But the night he was waiting to board one of the unseaworthy boats in Tripoli, the police raided the smuggler’s house. They chased Osman and he fell from the first floor of the building. He has been unable to walk since then.
Now, he is stuck in a run-down building in Gargaresh [a town not far west of Tripoli], in a tiny dark room that looks more like a cave. “When the thieves come, everybody runs away, but all I can do is to hide under the blankets, hoping they will not see me.”
Hasan and Osman made the decision to cross the Mediterranean Sea [to seek safety in Europe]. Along with [more than] 15,000 people in 2020 and 2021, they were intercepted by the Libyan coastguard and forcibly returned to Libya, where many were locked up in detention centers.
Losing all hope
In the main hangar, where people are kept, the only light that enters is from high-up windows close to the ceiling. Most of them are broken, but they are up there, [letting] in the cold and the rain rather than providing any proper ventilation. I entered the main area with [the] MSF medical team to distribute Plumpy’Nut, a high-calorie peanut paste we usually give to malnourished children. We distribute it to adults in the detention centers because we know they don’t receive enough food. Our teams have reported severe cases of malnutrition in detention centers in Tripoli before. By giving out nutritional supplements, we hope we can avoid more.
Detainees squat in long rows, their heels not touching the floor, their backs bent and their eyes looking down. There are roughly 150 people in front of me, but they seem to occupy such a small space.
Many of the people I spoke to had lost all hope. They felt like they were trapped in a loop, with no solutions, no choices and no options. They couldn’t go home, they couldn’t stay in the detention center and be treated like this, they couldn’t stay in Libya, and they couldn’t get to Europe. They had tried and were intercepted every time.
One day I met a group of people who had survived a shipwreck. I spoke to a man who had lost his brother that night. “Please convince the guards to let me call my mother,” he said. “I am sure she thinks I am dead too, I need to let her know I survived.”
In the months I worked in Libya I found myself time and again pondering the same questions: What are people missing to really understand what is going on in Libya? Are those suffering so unfamiliar to us? Do we think that Libya is so far away that what happens here is not our concern?
For quite some time now I’ve heard that people are tired of hearing stories from Libya. [Some] call it “compassion fatigue.” You will not find this fatigue in the MSF medical team who, every day for years, go to the detention centers and out into the communities of Tripoli to try to ensure people receive care. Every day they bear witness to the suffering of refugees and migrants caused by the lawlessness, the exploitation, the lack of protection, and the limited access to the most basic health care.
During one of our toughest days in Tripoli, my colleague was very moved and could not hide her tears. She told me, “You never get used to it.” [And] we should not.